It’s been a rough few years for Phat Luong. In 2010, shortly after winning Best Barber in our Best of Halifax edition and a few weeks before Christmas, the two storefront windows of his barbershop were smashed in. This December a vandal broke the line to his shops oil-tank, spilling hundreds of litres of fuel onto his property. And just last month someone made a complaint to police that he was selling liquor in his shop; he was investigated, but nothing was found.
“We have no clue who’s doing it,” he says.
But the problems keep coming. The oil spill has totalled over $190,000 in cleanup costs so far and the price tag keeps getting larger. Luong’s insurance will pay for a portion of the cleanup—$220,000 worth—but once he gets to that total, he’s on his own.
Whoever cut the line (Luong has captured the perp on camera, but his face is covered) can be charged with mischief over $5,000, but under the Nova Scotia Environment Act it’s Luong who’s stuck with the bill. “The cost for environmental cleanup is not cheap,” he says. “It all depends on what they have to do.”
According to the Insurance Bureau of Canada, domestic oil spills average between $250,000 and $500,000 in cleanup costs, with some projects costing considerably more. For Luong, costs of that kind would not only spell bankruptcy for his business, it would also devastate his family. That’s because Luong is the primary provider for his extended family in Vietnam and also one of the primary providers for his disabled mother in Halifax.
“I am the main income here. I have to look after everything,” he says. “I cannot lose this business.”
Domestic fuel spills are fairly common, says Paul Currie, a technical specialist at the provincial Department of Environment & Labour. “We do use a lot of furnace oil in the province. I think there are a couple hundred thousand domestic oil tanks. On that basis itself it’s fairly frequent.“
Currie says that many homeowners rely on private insurance to cover the cost of oil spills, but typically the homeowner pays out of pocket too. It may sound callous, he says, but homeowners are required to cover the costs of cleanup, regardless of whether or not they can afford to.
There is a bit of wiggle room. If the spill is not causing any immediate environmental damage, homeowners can apply to have the deadline extended past the ideal limit of four months. But even with an extension, homeowners generally have less than a year to complete the cleanup, and the possibility of a deadline extension doesn’t help Luong sleep any better at night.
“It still doesn’t make any difference,” he says. “In the end you still have to pay for that.”
So far Luong has been pleading his case to the inspector assigned to oversee the cleanup. The inspector is trying to work within his budget, Luong says, but there are no guarantees. Meanwhile, Luong worries about other bouts of vandalism and is convinced that someone is out to force him out of business. If his costs keep going up, they might succeed.
“I respect the environmental laws. I think we live in a good environment because of it, it’s a good idea,” he says. “But on the other side of that I am a victim too.”
This article appears in Apr 19-25, 2012.
It’s a damn shame what’s happening to him. If they ever catch the hooligan who cut the line either he should be responsible or, if he is a minor, his parents should be liable for all cleanup costs.
Private home and business owners shouldn’t have the burden of paying for environmental damage on their own. It was vandalism and it’s a community problem. The city government should have a fund for these things.
I’ve been going to Phat’s Barber Shop for 15 years now. You know how hard it is to find a good barber? I’ll be devastated if he goes out of business.
Whomever you are please leave him alone. I hope this is not a racist issue happening to drive him out. Business owners work very hard and long ours to make a living and pay significant taxes. I would suggest that you take a good look at yourself in the mirror and try to love yourself and your neighbours. Some counselling might help too. Be a winner and stop this nonsense. Thank you.
Halifax has a serious race problem. I was driven away from constant racial attacks too. The same person would keep going to the police claiming I was harrassing them so each time the police would break into my home without a warrant. The first time I was home and I filed a complaint but they did nothing. I even supplied evidence that the person had contacted me first but the police simply ignored me. I knew it was time to move when the police broke into my place again a few months later, and I suspect it was the same person who filed the fake police complaint against me in the first place though I have no proof.
My family is a client with a major competitor of this person’s firm, at first said person came to me all friendly and nicely, no doubt trying to score business or gain access/favour. When I gave this person the cold shoulder and told them to piss off the police harassments started. Sometimes I think I might move back there because I have friends there that I’d like to visit more often, but then I remembered that Halifax has a serious racial problem and it doesn’t look like it’s changed at all, so probably not.