With Americans craving political change, itβs been useful to see the US response to Fidel Castroβs resignation last week; the biggest change the northern hemisphere has seen in a while. Barack Obama said he would take a different approach than the trade embargo the States has maintained against Cuba since 1961, and meet Fidelβs successor Raul Castro βwithout preconditions.β Obama distinguished himself as the only presidential candidate to grasp that Americaβs long-standing policy has been futile.
Unsurprisingly, the regime of president George Bush marked the Cuban changing of the guard by reiterating the American status quo. βWe urge the Cuban government to begin a process of peaceful, democratic change by releasing all political prisoners, respecting human rights and creating a clear pathway toward free and fair elections,β said US Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice, displaying the sort of rhetoric that helped Fidel stay in power from 1959 onward, defying the American bullies. Americaβs dodgy record when it comes to clean elections, protecting rights and such makes Riceβs finger-pointing hypocritical. But thatβs the American way.
βSelective indignation has been the name of the game,β says Cuba watcher John Kirk. βIf you look at the human rights situation in Cuba in terms of civil and political human rights, itβs poor. If you look at the situation in terms of social and economic and cultural rights, itβs very good. If you compare Cuba to Mexico, Cuba looks light years better than Mexico. If you compare Cuba to Brazil, likewise. The problem is we donβt do that.β
Kirk is a professor in the Spanish department at Dalhousie University, and one of the worldβs foremost experts on Cuba. His first trip to the island was in 1976, and heβs been regularly visiting and publishing books ever since. The morning after our interview, he left for Havana with a group of local officials who want to learn about Cubaβs excellent health system. When NS premier John Savage led trade delegations to Cuba in 1994 and 1996—updating the historic cod-for-rum ties between Cuba and Nova Scotia—Kirk was Savageβs interpreter during the weeks of meetings with Fidel. He remembers the Cuban leader well.
βHe has piercing eyes that make you feel very nervous. Speaks very good English but hides behind an interpreter because it gives him time to reflect, an extra few seconds to think about a response. There were a couple times when I was speaking and he would say to me, βKirk, thereβs a nuance there that I think you need to understand.β And he would look at you, those eyes boring into you.β Castro is also βobsessed withβ public health, education and social equality, Kirk says.
βFor me he is the most important Third World political leader of the 20th century. What Cuban foreign policy has done in Africa and Latin America—Iβm doing a book at the moment on Cuban medical internationalism, and Cubaβs got 30,000 medical staff in 72 countries. It has offered 5,000 doctors to deal with AIDS in sub-Saharan Africa, if the west will come up with the drugs. So far the silence is deafening.
βCastro is an extraordinary human being, and a person who for 49 years has defied logic. To survive—I think the official government number is 638 assassination attempts—a lot of assassination attempts, a lot of acts of terrorism by the United States, heβs been an extraordinary Third World leader.β
Americaβs policy toward Cuba is shaped by the embittered Cuban-American community in Florida, and enabled by sloppy media coverage that perpetuates a cartoon version of Fidel and Raul Castro as Commie thugs. And you donβt have to be John Kirk to realize itβs not working. βThe solution,β Kirk says, βis for the United States to recognize that having had 10 American presidents vow to overthrow Castro, and having a record of zero in 10, that perhaps itβs time to change the strategy.β
This article appears in Feb 28 β Mar 5, 2008.


Great to hear that NS health officials are looking to Cuba for answers. The island’s emphasis on preventative medicine is definitely a model to follow. There are so many wonderful links between our province in Cuba – time for a Coast feature! π Start with the amazing Los Primos / HavanaFax initiative.