Cornwallis panel needs to proceed slowly, cautions HRM councillors

It’s been over a week since Halifax Regional Council voted for an expert panel to examine how the city commemorates its problematic founder, but there’s still no word on who will take part.

Officially, HRM has four names selected. Those individuals are being contacted by city staff for confirmation. Another four names will be selected by the Nova Scotia Assembly of Mi’kmaq Chiefs. The finalized group will then begin a process of historical analysis and public consultation that’ll last another six to eight months.

It’s an irritatingly slow process, no matter which side of the Edward Cornwallis debate you subscribe to. Councillor Shawn Cleary shares that frustration. But hey, that’s government for you.

“Listen, if it was up to me and you, we’d go take our chains and a pick-up truck and go take it down right now,” says the Halifax West Armdale representative. “That’s not how government works, and unfortunately, I’m now a part of government.”

Cleary introduced the idea of an expert panel back in the spring—ironically inspired by a performance from HRM poet laureate Rebecca Thomas that was written about the previous, narrowly defeated, debate on Cornwallis a year prior.

It’s perhaps a sign of progress that this latest request for an advisory panel easily passed, with only two votes against. But its recommendations will be non-binding. Council will still have to open up another round of debate on Cornwallis before making any decisions.

“What is going to be awesome at the end of this process is that, yes it’ll take long, but hopefully we will all be together in how we got there,” says Cleary. “I’m hopeful that this is a real learning opportunity for us as a city.”

Edward Cornwallis founded Halifax on orders of the British—and in violation of treaties with the Mi’kmaq—in 1749. That same year, the future governor of Nova Scotia issued a proclamation for Mi’kmaw scalps in an effort to drive out the area’s Indigenous population.

Centuries later, colonialist sympathies caused Cornwallis to be honoured with a north-end street, south-end park and bronze statue fashioned in his image.

Over the past few decades, however, calls to rethink why Halifax continues to celebrate an intolerant military commander have steadily increased.

During last week’s vote, several elected official offered their reassurances to the public that progress is—slowly, but surely—being made.

“The statue went up in 1931,” says mayor Mike Savage. “It wasn’t until last year [that] a motion went to council….Governments always have processes, but whatever happens has to be done in a way that has integrity.”

“I know it’s been a hard trail, but this is the first time we’ve actually been able to have this discussion,” Peninsula North councillor Lindell Smith told his colleagues. “So it’s going to take time. A lot of us would like this process to move faster, but we’re working in government.”

Back in July, some 300 people not working in government gathered at Cornwallis Park to try and topple the statue on their own—policy and process be damned. Instead, as a compromise, Cornwallis’ visage was covered (briefly) with a municipal tarp.

The organizers of the protest then presented the mayor with a call to action, asking him to remove the statue before Mi’kmaq History Month in October. Although Savage politely accepted the document, little came of its central demand.

Instead, the mayor says the municipality is strengthening its ties to Halifax’s Mi’kmaw residents through several ongoing initiatives. A staff report on the effectiveness of HRM’s commitment to truth and reconciliation, for instance, should be back to council in the next few weeks. The city is also on the verge of hiring its first ever Indigenous advisor. It recently approved a motion to try and help relocate the Mi’kmaw Native Friendship Centre, and HRM has plans for creating a Legacy Room inside City Hall.

“Our relationship with the Mi’kmaq is very important, and I think that they recognize that we’re taking steps in that direction,” says Savage.

The Cornwallis panel is another of those steps in the right direction, according to Cleary—a step towards rebuilding the relationship between settler Canadians and First Nations.

It’s just going to be a while before we get there. Making history takes time.

“We have to do this in a way that the Indigenous community can live with; that the city can live with; that the government can live with,” Cleary says. “Is that going to be fast enough for everyone? No. Is it fast enough for me? No. But it’s the process we have, and what’s great is it’s moving forward—inch-by-inch, step-by-step—but it is moving forward.”

Related Stories

Update: Matt Whitman all-lives-matters Cornwallis panel

Outspoken councillor faces blowback for his criticism of the committee tasked with judging Halifax’s problematic founder.

Masuma Khan is making history

The Dalhousie University student and outspoken political activist wants to better her hometown of Halifax. Just try and stop her.

Welcome to Mi’kma’ki

A primer on Mi’kmaq history and culture for new residents of K’jipuktuk.

Cornwallis tarp already removed

Halifax covers its shame—for a few hours anyway—but reconciliation still a long way off.

Daniel Paul on protest to topple Cornwallis statue: “If it goes, it goes”

Mi’kmaq author and historian says protesters are following up on path he started decades ago.

Rear admiral apologizes for Proud Boys’ behaviour

Alt-right chauvinists who disrupted Indigenous event on Canada Day facing disciplinary action and military police review.

De-celebrating Canada 150

The non-stop nationalistic party doesn’t leave much space for the critical reflection our country needs to acknowledge harms and move towards reconciliation.

Poet laureate heartened by council’s Cornwallis vote

“It’s overwhelming,” says Rebecca Thomas, about reconciliation motion she directly inspired.

“Destroy the Indians”

Edward Cornwallis had no desire for peaceful coexistence with this land’s original inhabitants, only to drive them from the peninsula “decisively and forever.”

Rhonda Britton’s call to action

Although she’s only been preaching in Halifax for the last 10 years, Rhonda Britton’s perspective and faith could help bridge the historical divide between police and the Black community.

New Art 2017: Raven Davis leads the tough conversations

Artist Raven Davis challenges the nationalistic status quo.

David Hendsbee surprised Halifax didn’t use a red tarp to cover Cornwallis statue

Jokes about smoking a peace pipe and concerns First Nations groups will want the keys to his house are some of the comments from the city councillor in over 500 pages of emails about Halifax’s controversial founder.

“It’s awe-inspiring in the ignorance.” Rebecca Thomas frustrated by David Hendsbee’s Cornwallis comments

Municipality’s poet laureate says councillor’s remarks show he “isn’t fit to represent ridings that have diverse individuals.”

Cornwallis statue is history

Council votes to temporarily remove racist monument in act of reconciliation.

Why Halifax’s Cornwallis should follow Montreal’s lead on the path to reconciliation

He should get “the full glare of history’s penetrating light.”

This article appears in Oct 5-11, 2017.