Putting trials on trial | City | Halifax, Nova Scotia | THE COAST

Putting trials on trial

Legal professor Elaine Craig's upcoming book holds Canada's justice system accountable for failing victims of sexual assault.

click to enlarge Putting trials on trial
Elaine Craig's new book will be available March 2018.

The urgent and vivid public discourse surrounding rape culture has perhaps never been so ubiquitous. The stampede of coverage in the wake of a (seemingly nonstop) list of allegations of sexual misconduct against powerful men in media, entertainment and government is not slowing down—if anything it seems to be gaining more traction all the time.

As more survivors come forward, renewed calls for action follow in quick succession.

All the while, a Halifax lawyer has been quietly and carefully documenting the Canadian justice system’s handling of sexual assault cases. The result of Elaine Craig’s sweeping investigation is being printed right now. Her book, Putting Trials on Trial: Sexual Assault and the Failure of the Legal Profession, is slated for release in early 2018.

“We seem to be in a moment,” Craig says, pointing to “unprecedented consideration of sexual assault and sexual harassment, and the legal system’s response to it.”

The associate professor at Dalhousie’s Schulich School of Law began research for her book back in 2010. This was long before the Harvey Weinstein and Louis C. K. bombshells from the New York Times confirmed what had been whispered about for years. It was before the allegations of sexual harassment against Al Franken, Charlie Rose, Dustin Hoffman, Kevin Spacey, Mark Halperin, Roy Moore, Glenn Thrush and dozens more came out over the past month. This was years before the Ghomeshi trial—years before Canadian judges were telling victims of sexual assault they should “keep your knees together” or that “clearly, a drunk can consent.”

Public scrutiny in Canada seems to have leapt forward when it comes to rape culture and issues surrounding the justice system. People are finally, mercifully, paying attention. That doesn’t mean anything much has changed.

The number of sexual assault cases deemed by police as “unfounded” remain mammoth, as the Globe and Mail has proven. Twenty years since this country introduced its rape shield laws, the numbers aren’t budging.

“Reporting rates have not increased,” Craig says. “Conviction rates have stayed the same. Survivors continue to experience the criminal justice system as traumatic.”

For years, feminists in the justice system and academia have been trying to draw attention to this inconsistency. Canada’s rape shield laws are held up internationally as the most rigorous, most robust provisions on the books. But the gold-standard system isn’t producing results.

“How can we have such powerful law reform, the most progressive changes in the world to the law of sexual assault and have it not impact on the ground in any real way?” Craig asks.

Her research on that question examines specific trials across Canada. Craig spent hours documenting and re-reading trial transcripts—in some cases, listening to the actual voices of complainants, witnesses and judges in the courtroom via audio transcripts.

Her writing provides concrete examples of systemic injustices. Her findings spare no one across the legal and justice professions.
“[There are] problematic attitudes and stereotypical thinking on the part of police, crown, defence and judges,” she says.

Craig has developed something of an expertise in the study of “whacking.” It’s the woefully-named term for a common tactic that seeks to “exploit the stereotypes and vulnerabilities inherent in sexual assault cases.” Put another way, it’s the aggressive and unfair questioning of victims on the stand. The practice is illegal in Canada and widely seen as unethical.

But as Craig’s book shows—through interviews with lawyers that hint at a common narrative amongst the criminal defence bar—whacking the complainant isn’t some antiquated technique of the past.

“There’s a disconnect there,” Craig explains, “[because] empirical evidence suggests that women continue to experience the trial process as deeply traumatic.”

But before such an issue can be addressed, it must be acknowledged.
“You’ve gotta convince the legal profession that this problem even exists.”

Canada’s justice system has a long way to go, and Craig says she doesn’t know how her academic research will be received. But she does know one thing for certain.

“This book is going to generate controversy.”

About time.

Support The Coast

At a time when the city needs local coverage more than ever, we’re asking for your help to support independent journalism. We are committed as always to providing free access to readers, particularly as we confront the impact of COVID-19 in Halifax and beyond.

Read more about the work we do here, or consider making a donation. Thank you for your support!

Comments (0)

Add a comment

Add a Comment

Recent Comments