Copy rights

Mount Saint Vincent University recently decided to stop using controversial anti-plagiarism service Mihira Lakshman gets the reaction.

photo Darryl James

For the entire school year, Krissy Arbuckle and Chantal Brushett have been on a mission to pull the plug on

Arbuckle and Brushett, two student union leaders at Mount Saint Vincent University, got on the website’s case in September after a student told them it was on a professor’s syllabus. On March 6, they successfully rallied the University’s senate to ban use of the site from campus until at least 2009. “This issue consumed our lives,” says Arbuckle, vice-president of academic affairs for Mount Saint Vincent’s student union. “At some points, we even dreamt about it. It took so much of our time.” is a subscription-only website available to universities that are willing to pay. It’s supposed to give professors a better chance at catching cheaters.

The website maintains a database of 1,000s of essays and online sources. A professor can run a student’s assignment through the database and will flag the assignment if it appears to be copied. The controversial website has been fodder for discussion in newspapers, internet chat rooms and campus hallways for the past month, since the Mount decided to ban it. Arbuckle and Brushett were especially worried about intellectual property, because stores students’ work on a commercial database.

Arbuckle says she doesn’t think it’s fair for a website to profit off a student’s work, without any compensation. makes money by keeping a database of students’ essays, she says. “So indirectly, the company is actually profiting off your paper,” Arbuckle says.

The website charges some university departments as much as $1,200 per year, depending on the school’s enrolment.

Many also felt the website created a poisonous learning environment, where students were automatically assumed to be guilty each time they passed in an assignment. The fallout from the Mount’s banning of has many at the university working damage control. Aside from the dozens of congratulatory emails from students at the Mount and across the country, Arbuckle says several negative letters and newspaper columns have hurt the university’s image. Some have suggested the Mount was trying to protect cheaters—getting soft on plagiarism. Others said a Mount degree would be worth less now that the university has banned

“Those comments are just ridiculous,” Arbuckle responds.

Robyn MacIsaac, a spokesperson for the Mount, says only three professors had on their syllabus—and she’s not sure if the database was ever used. Nancy Chessworth, one of the professors who wanted to use the software, wasn’t overly upset with the ban. “I have caught students cheating before without using,” she says. The old-fashioned methods of maintaining a good rapport with students, paying attention to patterns in their writing and checking sources all help to weed out cheaters, Chessworth says.

So does Google. The popular search engine is quickly becoming one of the best ways to check if an assignment has been copied from the internet, Arbuckle says. “The whole fracas about is silly,” Chessworth says. “The decision was made in consultation with .” For their part, Arbuckle and Brushett are saving every bit of information related to

“For us to accomplish something that no other students’ union in the country could do,” Arbuckle says, “it’s definitely rewarding.” Arbuckle hopes the scrapbook she’s compiling will be a helpful tool for student leaders at other universities looking for ways to fight back against

Dalhousie’s student union wants the university to allow students to opt out of submitting their work to A subcommittee of Dalhousie’s senate is looking into the situation and is expected to make a recommendation in May.

Saint Mary’s is also reviewing its policy on the website. But Paul Dixon, SMU’s registrar, says he doesn’t expect anything reactionary just because the Mount came out against There hasn’t been a big discussion about the issue on campus, he says.

Support The Coast

At a time when the city needs local coverage more than ever, we’re asking for your help to support independent journalism. We are committed as always to providing free access to readers, particularly as we confront the impact of COVID-19 in Halifax and beyond.

Read more about the work we do here, or consider making a donation. Thank you for your support!

Comments (0)

Add a comment

Add a Comment


Get more Halifax

The Coast Daily email newsletter is your extra dose of the city Monday through Friday. Sign up and go deep on Halifax.

Recent Comments