5173 South Street, 425-7111
This is always a hotly contested category—two years ago it was Thomasino’s, last year Salvatore’s prevailed and this year Thomasino’s is back on top. Of course, the real winner is you, dear reader, who gets a choice of the finest pizza places on the eastern seaboard.
Runner-up: Salvatore’s
5541 Young Street, 455-1133