Switch to the mobile version of this page.

Newsletters

Mobile

  
  Tweet
  
  Pin It
  
    Favourite
  Saving…

Print

Email

Share

December 21, 2017 News + Opinion » Voice of the City

A case against holiday giving

The current model we have for helping those in need is broken.

By Rylan Higgins

click to enlarge

Rylan Higgins is an assistant professor and chairperson of anthropology at Saint Mary’s University in Halifax. - VIA ISTOCK

Rylan Higgins is an assistant professor and chairperson of anthropology at Saint Mary’s University in Halifax.
VIA iSTOCK

It’s impossible to look around and not see that our society is broken—or to be invited to fix it, one can of soup at a time. Especially at this time of year, charity is presented as the best way to help those in need.

Real solutions to our problems, however, do not look like Giving Tuesday, or holiday food drives or seasonal fundraisers. Donation boxes at grocery stores aren’t the answer, nor are corporate giving campaigns.

People put a lot into charitable holiday pursuits and, in part, I understand why they jump quickly onto this bandwagon. It feels good, assuages guilt and seems like the right thing to do.

Anthropological observations made about charity, however, include several sobering points. Charity is largely impulse driven, for example—a lot like consumerism. It’s no surprise that non-profits often employ skilled marketing professionals.

Retailers clearly don’t want shoppers to think before they buy. A similar principle applies to giving. Thinking too deeply about charity reveals its pitfalls, including that the scale of giving never matches the problem.

Research shows, moreover, that philanthropy actually promotes inequality as the wealthy determine the nature of giving in ways that promote their own interests. The rich get tax breaks whether they give to their local opera house or to their local homeless shelter.

More broadly, society’s better off determine how giving happens. Middle-income people clearly prefer drives for clothing, food and toys over giving money directly to the poor. They are more comfortable giving to non-profits than to panhandlers.

Apparently, givers believe they know the needs of low-income people and don’t trust them to meet those needs themselves. The poor would likely squander our generosity, or so goes the thinking. A gently used jacket is safer than a toonie.

Yet globally there is growing evidence that when low-income people are given cash, they spend it on goods and services that improve their lives. Physical delivery of food, for example, is less efficient and effective than providing cash for people to buy their own.

My own anthropological observations confirm the growing awareness the charity is a powerful political tool that MLAs and MPs adore. It provides them seemingly unlimited Facebook photo ops, which serve well as campaign events throughout the year.

Charity also lets our leaders off the hook, given that governments rely on non-profits such as food banks as de facto extensions of government service, even when there is little in the way of government support.

The charity model matches well, moreover, with our current government’s approach to governing. There is, for example, an abundance of charity-like give-away initiatives. Free pizza, free hockey gear, free bowling, free haircuts, et cetera, et cetera—all brought to you by your local MLA.

And there are charity-like policies, like the recent decision to provide bus passes for people on income assistance. Why not simply increase the amount of income assistance? Likely because the provision of passes aligns nicely with society’s patronizing views on how to help those in need.

This all needs to change. The only way decision-makers will act less opportunistically is if we pressure them into abandoning this approach. And yet charities themselves are strictly limited in how much they can undertake such advocacy work and hesitate to exert such pressure.

In short, the current model we have for helping those in need is broken. It needs an overhaul that ordinary people will have to initiate. The solutions we need require sustained advocacy, not another season of giving.

———

 Voice of the City is a platform for any and all Halifax individuals to share their diverse opinions and writings. The Coast does not necessarily endorse the views of those published. Our editors reserve the right to alter submissions for clarity, length, content and style. Want to appear in this section? Submissions can be sent to voice@thecoast.ca.

Speaking of...

25 for 25: episode 2000

Jul 30, 2018
Here's to what Halifax is getting right

Dec 14, 2017
How to steal Christmas from a Who near you

Dec 7, 2017
More »

Tags: Voice of the City, Xmas, Holidays, Charity, Christmas, Inequality

Latest in Voice of the City

Offshore drilling and political theatre

Sep 20, 2018
Nova Scotia has responded to prison protest with nothing but contempt

Sep 8, 2018
Farewell (once again) to Nova Scotia

Sep 6, 2018
More »

Comments (4)

Showing 1-4 of 4

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:

By Email

Showing 1-4 of 4

Survey Asks

Who’s Nova Scotia’s worst tin-pot Doug Ford knockoff?

Coast Top Ten

Opinionated

OPINIONATED »

White noise

posted by REBECCA THOMAS, Aug 30/18

Letting your guard down to party loud and proud in the streets is a privilege students of colour don’t often have. comments 2

REALITY BITES »

Kathy Symington’s discrimination complaint will be heard in full

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 20/18

Nova Scotia's Human Rights Commission changes its mind about the former Halifax firefighter's case of systemic gender discrimination and harassment. comments 0

REALITY BITES »

25 for 25: episode 2007

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 17/18

Inside the Square with councillor Lindell Smith and Halifax's slow road to better biking with Kelsey Lane. comments 0

REALITY BITES »

Petition to rename Cornwallis Street delivered to city hall

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 14/18

Over 1,700 online signatures and 60 area residents want the controversial north end street's name changed to Rocky Jones Boulevard. comments 3

REALITY BITES »

Delay in addressing workplace racism a “slap in the face,” says councillor

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 13/18

“I just think, as a municipality, it looks more reactive than proactive.” comments 0

REALITY BITES »

Planner's exit could impact Centre Plan

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 12/18

Mayor is sad to see Jacob Ritchie leave city hall, but what his departure means for HRM's new planning bible remains to be seen. comments 0

REALITY BITES »

25 for 25: episode 2006

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 10/18

Reuniting the (almost) original cast of Street Cents, AKA Jonathan Torrens, Jamie Bradley, Benita Ha and Brian Heighton. comments 0

REALITY BITES »

Oh word, Rick Mehta was fired

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 7/18

Acadia University terminates professor after investigation into racist, sexist comments made both in and out of the classroom. comments 1

REALITY BITES »

City hall lawyers say smoking ban needs to include tobacco

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 7/18

Halifax staff reason it'll be nearly impossible to prosecute cannabis smokers if we can't also prosecute cigarette smokers. comments 1

REALITY BITES »

Matt Whitman and Faith Goldy

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 7/18

Halifax councillor appears to be a fan of the outspoken white nationalist running for mayor in Toronto. comments 1

REALITY BITES »

Justice minister finally responds to Burnside prison protest

posted by JACOB BOON, Sep 6/18

Mark Furey claims Nova Scotia respects its prisoners and protects their human rights, while sidestepping actual demands from protesting inmates. comments 1

SHOPTALK »

Maritime Makers make it on their own

posted by DANIELLE MCCREADIE, Sep 20/18

After splitting from Etsy, the annual craft market will go on as planned: “We don’t need Etsy, we just need each other.” comments 0

SHOPTALK »

Guided Tour - Quinpool Road

Sep 20/18

Another Quinfest has come and gone, and not without some good fun had by all. Quinfest celebrated the diversity on the street, and had a little something for everyone. comments 0