A case against holiday giving
The current model we have for helping those in need is broken.
By Rylan Higgins
It’s impossible to look around and not see that our society is broken—or to be invited to fix it, one can of soup at a time. Especially at this time of year, charity is presented as the best way to help those in need.
Real solutions to our problems, however, do not look like Giving Tuesday, or holiday food drives or seasonal fundraisers. Donation boxes at grocery stores aren’t the answer, nor are corporate giving campaigns.
People put a lot into charitable holiday pursuits and, in part, I understand why they jump quickly onto this bandwagon. It feels good, assuages guilt and seems like the right thing to do.
Anthropological observations made about charity, however, include several sobering points. Charity is largely impulse driven, for example—a lot like consumerism. It’s no surprise that non-profits often employ skilled marketing professionals.
Retailers clearly don’t want shoppers to think before they buy. A similar principle applies to giving. Thinking too deeply about charity reveals its pitfalls, including that the scale of giving never matches the problem.
Research shows, moreover, that philanthropy actually promotes inequality as the wealthy determine the nature of giving in ways that promote their own interests. The rich get tax breaks whether they give to their local opera house or to their local homeless shelter.
More broadly, society’s better off determine how giving happens. Middle-income people clearly prefer drives for clothing, food and toys over giving money directly to the poor. They are more comfortable giving to non-profits than to panhandlers.
Apparently, givers believe they know the needs of low-income people and don’t trust them to meet those needs themselves. The poor would likely squander our generosity, or so goes the thinking. A gently used jacket is safer than a toonie.
Yet globally there is growing evidence that when low-income people are given cash, they spend it on goods and services that improve their lives. Physical delivery of food, for example, is less efficient and effective than providing cash for people to buy their own.
My own anthropological observations confirm the growing awareness the charity is a powerful political tool that MLAs and MPs adore. It provides them seemingly unlimited Facebook photo ops, which serve well as campaign events throughout the year.
The charity model matches well, moreover, with our current government’s approach to governing. There is, for example, an abundance of charity-like give-away initiatives. Free pizza, free hockey gear, free bowling, free haircuts, et cetera,
And there are charity-like policies, like the recent decision to provide bus passes for people on income assistance. Why not simply increase the amount of income assistance? Likely because the provision of passes aligns nicely with society’s patronizing views on how to help those in need.
This all needs to change. The only way decision-makers will act less opportunistically is if we pressure them into abandoning this approach. And yet charities themselves are strictly limited in how much they can undertake such advocacy work and hesitate to exert such pressure.
In short, the current model we have for helping those in need is broken. It needs an overhaul that ordinary people will have to initiate. The solutions we need require sustained advocacy, not another season of giving.
Related Stories
-
800 Sobeys employees laid off just in time for the holidays
Nov 24, 2017 -
Clearcutting our losses
Oct 5, 2017 -
The holidays make me reflect on my mother
Dec 26, 2016 -
Talking points to help you survive the holidays
Dec 1, 2016 -
Good things come in small packages this holiday
Dec 1, 2016 -
How to fake a banging NYE on social media
Dec 24, 2015
Latest in Voice of the City
Comments (4)
Showing 1-4 of 4
Reality Bites
REALITY BITES »
Martha Paynter talks about abortion on the big screen
posted by CAORA MCKENNA, Jul 19/19
Don’t worry about missing Unplanned in theatres, here’s seven on-screen representations worth watching comments 0
REALITY BITES »
First phase of transit priority approved for Robie and Young streets
posted by CAORA MCKENNA, Jul 17/19
Short-term congestion in exchange for long term improvements comments 0
REALITY BITES »
Nova Scotia makes changes for non-binary birth certificates
posted by JESSICA R. DURLING, Jul 9/19
Option to have an X or no indicator now available comments 0
REALITY BITES »
This shit is bananas
posted by CAORA MCKENNA, Jun 28/19
Halifax Public Gardens’ June plant of the month is quite appealing comments 0
Shoptalk
SHOPTALK »
Safer Space Massage caters to all bodies and identities
posted by VICTORIA WALTON, Jul 17/19
Massage therapist Leah Inman wants to fill a void in the queer community. comments 0
SHOPTALK »
Steph McNair prioritizes non-binary beauty with Maneland
posted by ALLISON SAUNDERS, Jul 17/19
After 10 years working in hair, the Halifax artist and stylist debuts her own space. comments 0
SHOPTALK »
NS Kayak and ATV Outside Adventure Tours heads "out and away"
posted by ALLISON SAUNDERS, Jul 11/19
Chris White's sees his personalized kayak trips as a tool for adventure comments 0
SHOPTALK »
GUIDED TOUR: DOWNTOWN HALIFAX
Jul 11/19
Halifax’s downtown is the business capital of Atlantic Canada, a place of bank towers and bustle. But savvy visitors can find boutique experiences here too, the sort of shops, services and tastes that make Halifax unique. comments 0
SHOPTALK »
Vintage clothing for plus bodies, by plus bodies
posted by MORGAN MULLIN, Jul 3/19
Online thrift shops Fat Chance Vintage and Kitsch District look outside of straight sizes and binaries to provide inclusive, accessible second-hand clothing. comments 0
Guides
- About Us |
- Our Staff |
- Contact Us |
- Advertise |
- Work With Us |
- Send us a Tip |
- Privacy Policy |
- Comments Policy |
-
RSS Feeds
|
- Archives
