Pin It

Savage Love 

Dan says don't trust a smoker.

Once again, Savage Love is given over to letters from readers who made the largest donations to the campaigns to preserve marriage equality in California (, protect same-sex couples in Florida ( and defeat Stephen Harper in Canada (better luck next time). I neglected to ask readers to send dough to the campaign against an anti-gay-marriage amendment in Arizona, too (it's not too late:, because I am a bad, bad man. OK, on to this week's top donors...

Q: When I met my girlfriend, she had recently quit smoking. She knew from the very beginning that smoking is a deal-breaker for me, but despite the encouragement from me and all her friends, she keeps having "lapses." I haven't dumped her over this because we live far apart at the moment. However, I feel very firmly that we can't take the next step---one of us moving to be with the other---until she kicks this habit for good. She has always insisted that she wants to, and she knows how much smoking bothers me. But at what point will I know if she has finally quit? My fear is that there will always be another "lapse" coming. She is so great in every other way that I don't want to blow her off prematurely, and I want her to quit for her own health, too. Am I being an unreasonable perfectionist?

---Do Not Use My Name

A: Here's my bought-and-paid-for advice, DNUMN: Beware the smoker who stops---or "quits"---just long enough to convince you that her smoking days are behind her and then, once you're living together or married or otherwise hopelessly entangled, suddenly experiences one final and everlasting "lapse." Be clear and up front: Smoking is a deal-breaker if she moves across the country to live with you, it's a deal-breaker if you marry her, it's a deal-breaker now, it's a deal-breaker forever.

Q: I don't have a question. I have a story.

My parents had an unusual strategy for sex education. Instead of picking a day to have a birds-bees discussion, they first explained all the mechanics of the penis/vagina/uterus/baby when I was six months old. This was to give them practice. Then, as I got older, any question I asked that was moderately related to sex got me the whole of the penis/vagina/uterus/baby story again.

Fast-forward to sophomore year. While playing a drinking game, people were asked to retell the story of when they got The Talk. But I never got The Talk because I grew up with it. So on winter break, I demanded The Talk from dad. He came up with a few quips---sex is easy, sleeping in the same bed is hard. But the next day my mother pulled me aside."So I understand that you and your father had a conversation yesterday," my delightfully WASP-y and cheerful mother said.

"I want you to forget everything he said and remember this. Whatever you're doing, do it slower. Whatever you're doing, do it softer. And whatever you're doing, ask more questions."She turned around and walked away as I picked up my jaw from my floor.


A: I don't want to contradict your mother, J, but for the record: Some folks like it fast and hard, and prefer barked orders to thoughtful questions. But it's a sweet story, J. Thanks for sharing.

Q: I am a bisexual woman in a nonmonogamous marriage with a lesbian. We met one Sunday afternoon through an ad in our local alternative newsweekly. It was supposed to be a booty call, but Jennifer is so smart, witty and just plain good that I had to have some more of her and her milky-white breasts.

The sex started off fantastic---for the first six months, every time we got down it was the best sex I've ever had. Eight years later, we've had lots of sex toys, some gents and ladies on the side, and a few sex parties, and we are just as passionate and creative in bed as ever. We respect each other's sexual autonomy and our other partners, as well as our own relationship. Domestically, we are very compatible and even agree on how to spend our money: good causes, travelling and a Tempur-Pedic bed. Things are fantastic.

My question: Could I be any more smug?


A: You've stumped me, Holly. But thanks for sharing your fortune and your good fortune.

Q: I'm an American man but I'm writing from Canada, where my husband and I live. Please remind everyone that even though defeating Prop 8 is vital, getting rid of the federal "Defense of Marriage Act" is equally important. My hubby cannot live there with me until the DOMA is repealed, no matter what happens in California or any other state. Many people don't get that state and federal marriage laws are two different things.OK, here's our pressing question: What is the proper threesome etiquette once the good times are over? What do you do with your third? I say we should roll over and make room in the bed, while my husband thinks we should (nicely) toss the guy out. What say you?

--Married And Gay In Canada

A: I'm with your partner, MAGIC, unless:If it's pissing rain outside or freezing cold, or if you live in a neighbourhood that's unsafe to stroll through alone at 4am or if your third ditched his friends---and his ride---to come home with you and the husband, MAGIC, then you should offer to the third to stay the night. But no third worth inviting back will accept. A good third knows to say thanks and get out---or eat it and beat it---so that his hosts can decompress, check in with each other and resume the open, unself-conscious farting that characterizes all long-term relationships.

Q: Could you mention my recycled t-shirt website,, in the column? Here's how the site works: Every day I post a new (used) shirt. Each one costs $7 and a dollar of that goes to restoring urban rivers.

--Tim Cigelske

A:I don't see the connection between urban rivers and used t-shirts, Tim, and I think urban rivers are in serious trouble if we're restoring them one-dollar-per-used-t-shirt-sold-via-website-at-a-time, but thanks for the donation and here's your plug.

Well, hey, that was fun! But next week I'll be selecting letters using my tried-and-true method: Sit in a bar, have a few drinks, read a few hundred emails, respond to ones I find interesting/appalling/nauseating. And a word to the hundreds of folks who made donations and are waiting on personal responses from me: I'm a bit overwhelmed. Perhaps I should have made the cutoff for advice $100, not $25. I'll get to everybody, but it's going to take a week or two. But everyone who made a donation will hear from me before we go to the polls November 4 and vote for Barack Obama.


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Latest in Savage Love

    Defining The Trump Talk


    Defining The Trump Talk

    posted by DAN SAVAGE, Oct 20/16

    A reader suggests the conversation we have with our daughters about terrible men be dubbed The Trump Talk. comments      0

    Senior moments


    Senior moments

    posted by DAN SAVAGE, Oct 13/16

    Advice for the aged, including tips on how to find a younger woman, pleasing your porn-obsessed lady and cuddle buddies. comments      0

    Vulva culture


    Vulva culture

    posted by DAN SAVAGE, Oct 6/16

    I can’t solve my recurring vulva problems! Plus: I’m a lady who loves biking but not crotch pain. Can you help? comments      0

    The one-time cheater


    The one-time cheater

    posted by DAN SAVAGE, Sep 29/16

    If you’re sure it was a mistake, maybe keep it to yourself. Plus: Is my boyfriend’s online behaviour racist? comments      0

    Ready to date, now what?


    Ready to date, now what?

    posted by DAN SAVAGE, Sep 22/16

    Whether you’re a twentysomething teacher or closeted 64-year-old gay man, it’s totally possible! Dan shows you how. comments      0

    More Hands, fewer butts


    More Hands, fewer butts

    posted by DAN SAVAGE, Sep 15/16

    Dan fields readers’ personal requests to porn stars and Instagram celebrities. comments      0

  • More »

Coast Top Ten

Recent Comments

In Print This Week

Vol 24, No 21
October 20, 2016

Cover Gallery »

Real Time Web Analytics

© 2016 Coast Publishing Ltd.