Q My new girlfriend blurted out that she had a cuckolding past with her ex-husband. She says her ex badgered her into arranging "dates" with strangers and that he picked the guys. Her ex would then watch her having sex with a guy in a hotel room. The ex only watched and didn't take part. I am really bothered by her past. She says she did it only because her ex pressured her into it and she wanted to save her marriage, so she agreed. But I suspect she may have enjoyed it and may have been testing me to see if I wanted to be a cuck. What should I do? I am really torn by my feelings toward her. —Confused In NOVA
A You suspect she may have enjoyed fucking those other men? I hope she enjoyed fucking those other men—and you should too, CINOVA. Because even if cuckolding wasn't her fantasy, even if she fucked those other men only to delight her shitty ex-husband, anyone who cares about this woman should hope the experiences she had with those other men weren't overwhelmingly negative, completely traumatizing or utterly joyless.
And, yes, people will sometimes broach the subject of their own sexual interests/fantasies using the passive voice or a negative frame because they're afraid of rejection or they want an easy out or both. ("My ex was into this kinda extreme thing, and I did it because I felt I had to." "That's gross." "Yeah, I totally hated it.") But cuckolding is almost always the husband's fantasy—it's rare for the wife to initiate cuckolding scenes/relationships—so odds are good that your girlfriend is telling you the truth about those other men being her ex-husband's idea/fantasy and not hers.
As for whether she's testing you: That's a pretty easy test to fail, CINOVA. Open your mouth and say, "Cuckolding isn't something I would ever want to do. The thought of you with another man isn't a turn-on for me. Not at all." It's an easy F.
If you can't let this go, if you can't get over the sex your girlfriend had with her ex-husband and those other men, if you can't hope she had a good time regardless of whose idea it was, if you can't take "I'm not interested in cuckolding you!" for an answer, then do your girlfriend a favour and break up with her. She just got out from under a shitty husband who pressured her into "cheating." The last thing she needs now is a shitty boyfriend who shames her for "cheating."
Q My husband is Native American. I'm white. We've been together 16 years, raising a couple kids. We love each other very much, so this isn't a deal-breaker. I've got a thing for his long black hair. He's a drop-dead gorgeous man, and while I gave up asking that he wear a breechcloth once in awhile, I wish he would grow out his hair. I'm willing to wear (and do) anything he asks. He's somewhere to the left of Sherman Alexie when it comes to this stuff, but could you tell me why I'm so wrong? The one time I made enough of a fuss, he grew his hair out and never washed it just to spite me. A long time ago, he participated in a sun dance, and he looked incredible. I guess that makes me a blasphemous pervert, but really? Is asking for a couple of braids so wrong? —Whitey McWhite Wife
A I forwarded your email to Sherman Alexie, the award-winning poet, novelist, essayist and filmmaker. Your question must have touched a nerve, WMW, because Alexie's response arrived while my computer was still making that woooosh-sending-email sound.
"What does 'to the left of Sherman Alexie' mean in this context?" he writes. "I doubt there are very many native dudes more leftist than me! And long hair on Indian men is more conservative and more tribal, anyway—more ceremonial. More of a peacock thing, really. And a lot of work! My native wife certainly misses my long hair. But I don't miss the upkeep and I don't miss answering questions about my hair. I mean, I cut my hair 13 years ago (more than 25 percent of my life ago), and some people still ask me about it! Thirteen years! Also, native men tend to cut their hair as they age. Long hair is generally a young Indian man's gig, culturally speaking.
"I would venture that native dude is tired of being romanticized, ethnocized, objectified. We Indians get enough of that shit in the outside world. Maybe this dude doesn't want that in bed. Or maybe he just likes the way he looks with shorter hair. Because I am getting so gray, long hair would make me look like a warlock having a midlife crisis. Maybe this Indian dude is just sick of all the sociopolitical shit that comes with long hair. Maybe it kills his boner. Talking about it has certainly killed my boner."
Q Why would you call blumkins "sexist"? Are you excluding the idea that gay, bi and trans people might participate? There are many sexual practices that are degrading. If the partner consents, how is it "sexist"? Lastly, have you considered that a heterosexual female may want a blumkin of her own? —The Problem Isn't Always Sexism
A Go to Urban Dictionary and read every definition for "blumkin," TPIAS. There are nine of them. While almost all of the proposed definitions—including the top one—are gendered ("Taking a nice shit while your woman is sucking your cock"), even definitions that aren't gendered ("Getting a blowjob while taking a stinky shit") include examples of usage that are gendered ("Anthony really enjoyed it when Christy gave him a blumkin last night"). While a gay dude could suck his man's cock while he was taking a shit, and while a trans man could go eat his cis girlfriend's pussy while she was dropping a deuce, the whole conversation about blumkins—which are mythical, TPIAS—isn't about consensual degrading sex play. It's about the symbolic degradation of women.
And that's sexist. It's like gerbilling: Everyone has a butthole, anyone can walk into a pet store and buy a gerbil, paper-towel tubes are everywhere. But gerbilling is always described as a gay sex act. The fact that straight, bi, asexual or even deceased people could theoretically have their asses gerbilled doesn't make joking about gerbiling not homophobic. The anatomical technicality doesn't exonerate gerbiling. Same goes for blumkins.
SAVAGE LOVE »
posted by DAN SAVAGE, Dec 1/16
My boyfriend thinks it’s fine to play with himself whenever he wants. Is he right? Plus: Sucking and squeezing. comments 1
SAVAGE LOVE »
posted by DAN SAVAGE, Nov 24/16
My boyfriend’s into vore—the fantasy of being eaten or eating another creature alive. How do I accomodate? Plus: Toy shopping! comments 0
SAVAGE LOVE »
posted by DAN SAVAGE, Nov 17/16
What’s to be done now, in the face of president-elect Trump, and his documented hatred of nearly everyone? Fuck, and fight. comments 1
SAVAGE LOVE »
posted by DAN SAVAGE, Nov 10/16
My poly primary doesn’t want me dating anyone else with her name. Is that fair? Plus: Should I settle for a just-OK guy? comments 0
SAVAGE LOVE »
posted by DAN SAVAGE, Nov 3/16
Dan dives into the world of cuckolding: Those who love it, those who want to and those who are scared of it ruining everything. comments 0
SAVAGE LOVE »
posted by DAN SAVAGE, Oct 27/16
I want sex every night, but my wife is only offering one. I don’t like porn. Now what? Plus: Breaking up is not a conversation. comments 0
Monday should be "Take Your Kids to the Legislature Day!" Or would that make the…
It doesn't matter who you vote for, you get the same results. We need to…
Ooooh, the oil and capitalist shills are in bloom....