1573 Barrington Street, 422-4544
Sometimes, a cigar is just a cigar. And when that’s all you want, you head to Sievert’s. The venerable old shop—on Barrington since 1909—offers all kinds of cigars, including the premium Trinidad. If you’re looking to celebrate with one of those babies, it’ll cost you around $41.
Runner-up: MacDonald Tobacco
1903 Barrington Street, 423-6647