Though Darrell’s has owned this category for many years, it’s a competitive one. Brooklyn’s big burger is hot on the heels of the peanut butter king, but has yet to topple him. Yes, we use the masculine when discussing the peanut butter burger---if burgers had genders, this one would certainly be a guy. This is a burger with all the fixings, including the genius addition of peanut butter. We know it sounds weird, but he’s a burger who will treat you right. He’ll hit the spot. Trust us.
First Runner-up: Brooklyn Warehouse
’s Brooklyn Burger
Second Runner-up: The Chickenburger
’s Chicken Burger