My Other Brother Darrell’s, 5576 Fenwick, 492-2344
For some reason, the now defunct Libertine always got all the credit for putting peanut butter on its hamburgers. But My Other Brother Darrell’s has been doing it for as long as its been in business—almost 10 years now. “A lot of people are afraid to try it,” says server Nicki McEachern, “but once they do, they almost never order anything else.” MOBD’s also has non-peanut butter burgers and a veggie burger too, all of them gourmet-alicious.
Runner-up: The Granite Brewery, 1222 Barrington, 423-5660