Anti antigens: the H1N1 refusers 

Some people refuse to get themselves and their children vaccinated against H1N1. One explains why.

Rachael Smith-Bakhache won't be dragging around her kids for H1N1 shots this week. And not anytime after that, either.

"It's my choice," says the 38-year-old mother of two. "And I don't think I have to stand up and tell you why it's my choice."

But she will, if you ask.

And explaining why her family won't be vaccinated against H1N1 influenza is easy for Smith-Bakhache, because her reasons aren't the most obvious and easily refuted---too busy to stand in line, too pissed off about the seeming lack of organization, too lame to Google clinic locations and times.

Smith-Bakhache says, simply: "There are other ways."

Neither of Smith-Bakhache's kids---an 11-year-old girl and a boy just past one---has ever been vaccinated. Not for mumps, rubella, polio. None of it.

"We are a holistic family. We have been right from the get-go."

Smith-Bakhache replaces immunizations with a host of other tactics; the same ones she'll keep up, or even ramp up, instead of lining up for an H1N1 poke. She does homeopathy, uses natural remedies and practices homegrown immunity-boosting---she lists breastfeeding her one-year-old, giving her daughter limited amounts of sugar and dairy products, plus supplements like garlic pills and feeding everyone fresh vegetables and natural meats.

"Some parents think that's not going to matter," says Smith-Bakhache. "But it's little steps. [It's like] saving the environment---turn your lights off. It adds up."

Smith-Bakhache can't understand why parents will pony up their kids for a vaccination when they don't bother with everyday measures to keep them healthy---she cites sending them to school without proper clothing, "with a lunch that is full of sugar. Even dairy products, that is something I do not do. Sending your children to school with a healthy lunch is very important. They need fresh vegetables. They need lots of fresh water."

But there's a bigger piece of pandemic preparedness that goes along with all of Smith-Bakhache's baby steps and everyday actions.

"I am always keyed into my children," she says. "I have watched [my daughter's] behaviour, her diet, just keying into, and being focused on, my children and not being too busy within my own life."

That's what people should be spending time thinking about, Smith-Bakhache says. "I mean, why are people putting so much thought into [the vaccine]?"

If you ask other parents to answer that question, they will likely cite the H1N1 deaths of 10-year-old Vanetia Warner and 13-year-old Evan Frustaglio, two otherwise healthy Ontarians who died after contracting the virus. Frustaglio, a minor league hockey player in grade eight, was sick for only 48 hours. A friend told me yesterday it's outright terror from hearing of those deaths that is driving the rolled sleeves of her and her kids to the closest clinic. Before she heard about Warner and Frustaglio, she didn't really see the point of getting the shots.

And those mind-rending deaths aren't the only thing to think about: a Journal of the American Medical Association study last month found two-thirds of Canadians who fall gravely ill or die from H1N1 are young, healthy women---exactly the profile of Smith-Bakhache.

But Smith-Bakhache has run through the what-ifs.

What if she is a vector---someone who doesn't get sick but passes the virus along?

She says the best way to avoid that is to steer clear of the virus in the first place, which she's already doing.

What if one of her kids gets sick?

"I will feel horrible," she says. "Definitely. And like maybe it wasn't the right choice for me to make."

But she still thinks it is the right one, in the context of the way she raises her family. And, after all, according to the Centres for Disease Control, the regular flu kills 36,000 people a year in the US alone.

Smith-Bakhache's husband works in the armed forces, and was vaccinated at work this week. Still, he told his non-vaccinating wife, "I trust your judgment." Smith-Bakhache's mom reserved opinion, telling her daughter (who, yes, was immunized by her parents as a child), "You do what you want to do." Smith-Bakhache admits: "A girlfriend of mine, she is going to be outraged."

But Smith-Bakhache can let it roll off her back. That's kind of her style, really: taking matters into her own hands, despite what the rest of the world is telling her. That, and reiterating that vaccination is her choice.

"My children are healthy," she says, "because of other choices I have made."

Comments (106) RSS

Showing 1-5 of 106

Add a comment | All comments »

@Jennifer: I am not going to take the time to pick apart your argument, as it is evident that you are seriously deluded about your sources of information. I watched the You Tube video you suggested. Yes it would be frightening IF TRUE but I also did some research on the individual, who turns out to be a classic nut-job. She was NEVER a Minister of Health for the Finnish Government. She also believes she had 100 experiences with extraterrestrials and holds other ludicrous opinions.

No one is forcing the vaccine down your throat! Please be reasonable while taking part in the discussion and base your argument on verifiable facts. As the saying goes "You are entitled to your own opinion, but not to your own facts."

Merry Xmas!

Posted by DaveChapman on December 23, 2009 at 2:22 PM | Report this comment

Well Jennifer according to the news on the radio today about half of the HRM isn't vaccinated, so there's as many people out there like you & I, as there are those who are...hmmmm, more trusting than you & I. I'm still waiting for the unvaccinated half to start dying in droves...I'm really glad I'm not holding my breath, while waiting ;)

Posted by More on December 14, 2009 at 6:28 PM | Report this comment

I think this flu shot is a very bad idea...it has not been tested, and excuse me, but where's the pandemic? Other than making the pharmaceutical companies rich, what else is it good for? It's already made a number of people very ill, and I distrust the zeal with which governments and health authorities are shoving this down our throats.

There is an excellent You Tube video that contains an interview with a former Minister of Health for Finland that's quite frightening, definitely worth watching., http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nTgyakGAddM

Have faith in your own immune systems! Don't randomly take a drug that has not been thoroughly tested or approved, it could be fatal

Posted by Jennifer on December 3, 2009 at 5:50 PM | Report this comment

The adjuvanted vaccine is based on GSK's pandemic vaccine platform technology originally designed and tested using H5N1 as the virus strain. Adjuvanted vaccines use less antigen (killed virus) and thus can be manufactured faster than non-adjuvanted vaccine which requires more virus to be grown in eggs and is a time-consuming process. Also, the adjuvant promotes a more robust immune response which provides immunity somewhat faster and with higher antibody titres. The government ordered the ajuvanted vaccine to make sure more doses would be available sooner. Despite the vaccine shortage, inocculating 25% of the population in just under 2 weeks isn't that small a feat. So, I'm not convinced the decision to use adjuvanted vaccine was corner or cost cutting measure as much as it was a (arguably necessary) time saving measure.


Posted by Miles (from home) on November 17, 2009 at 1:06 AM | Report this comment

On the topic of the H1N1 vaccine, since that is the main topic of the article...

Put out one without the adjuvant and without the mercury compound (thiomersal), and I might get it. NEITHER ARE REQUIRED for this or any vaccine to work (immunologists in the crowd please chime in if need be), and both could qualify as pharmaceutical company corner-cutting (in a small way perhaps, but still) in order to increase profits.

No conspiracy theory here...that's what companies do. Adjuvant-free vaccines cost more to produce, as do single-dose formulations (less need for preservation). Although some people, including our health authorities, do not consider it worth the effort to prevent Canadians from being injected with these unnecessary ingredients, it is completely reasonable for me or anyone else to not want to take those risks, as small as they might be.

Posted by No Dogma on November 16, 2009 at 10:55 PM | Report this comment

Add a comment

Coast Top Ten

From the Archives

  • Dry ice's spooky airs

    When Halloween calls for a scary atmosphere, you can buy one, cheap. Tom Fleet tells us everything we need to know about dry ice.
    • Oct 29, 2009
  • Doing it right, finally

    Graham Murphy's funeral pre-planning business helps consumers with the only thing they really must buy.
    • Oct 8, 2009
  • Dalhousie's tea-riffic drinking society

    The Dal Tea Drinkers’ Society is doing something progressive, sort of, but it’s not a big deal. A nice cuppa makes it all go down okay.
    • Sep 10, 2009
  • City diner

    Streets and parks are a buffet table for urban forager Jen Stotland.
    • Sep 24, 2009
  • More»

Recent Comments

  • Re: Lowedown, the final curtain

    • I saw the notice as well, I hope you're not ginna take over from that…

    • on January 7, 2010
  • Re: Halifax's hidden racism

    • racism is something to always be aware of, but in this case, if the hair…

    • on January 7, 2010
  • Re: Lowedown, the final curtain

    • Well, I must say, you will be missed in the hallowed pages (web and paper)…

    • on January 7, 2010
  • Re: Lowedown, the final curtain

    • Great news that you're sticking with the features, Lezlie. I look forward to the next…

    • on January 7, 2010
  • Re: Lowedown, the final curtain

    • Lezlie, I've always admired your ability to provoke through your column. Whether I agreed or…

    • on January 7, 2010

People who saved…

In Print This Week

Vol 17, No 33
January 7, 2010

Cover Gallery »


© 2010 Coast Publishing Ltd.